Do I need another Bogner?

Epsilon

Hi all,

I've been on the verge of picking up a Bogner New Yorker 1x12 combo but I'm trying to talk myself out of it. I currently have a Bogner Atma head, running through a Bogner 1x12 open back cab. I love the Atma, and with the three gain modes it covers a lot of territory. The clean channel is also surprisingly versatile, and gets some convincing blackface and tweed sounds.

I don't know if anyone has first-hand experience with a New Yorker, but is it likely to bring anything to the table that the Atma doesn't? Part of me likes the idea of having a small-ish combo specifically for clean and low gain sounds, but I wonder if the New Yorker is just likely to duplicate functionality that I already have. Any views appreciated!

Zoolooter

I have a New Yorker and absolutely love it. Great clean, brown face and tweed tones. Never tried the Atma, but doubt the New Yorker will give you much more. Maybe a subtle difference with the 6V6's. 

Also depends if your getting a bargain or not.

octatonic

Yes.
What was the question?

Roland

No. Love the one you’re with.