It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Subscribe to our Patreon, and get image uploads with no ads on the site!
Base theme by DesignModo & ported to Powered by Vanilla by Chris Ireland, modified by the "theFB" team.
Comments
I'll own up to having recently bought my sixth Les Paul. My collection now consists of an Epiphone, 3 Gibsons, a Conversion, a Trussart, and the the one I made. I still have them all, though I really should get around to selling the Epiphone. They're my favourite solid bodied guitar. They're all, to a degree, different from each other.
Very happy I made the choice, cost me a little more than a new Gibson CC - but will at worst break even over time, as opposed to losing money on a new Gibson, and there is a difference (without wanting to start a vintage vs new debate).
Of course the danger with conversions is that you need to get a good one, but that's the same for everything.
If I didn't have this, I'd look very closely at a used Gil Yaron - they are out there, and very close
A late 50s Les Paul standard has become almost a mythical beast, you can talk yourself into trying to become part of that mythology, or you can keep your head screwed on and realise that they are just guitars.
I'm not totally immune to the romance of old guitars and my favourite guitar is also a Les Paul, but it really is the most bullshit industry out there.
Get an R9 and gig the paint off it, make your own history.
(formerly miserneil)
if the OP wants the vintage vibe without breaking the bank then have the said R9 refin’d. This is what I did with my R0 which was refin’d by Florian Jäger. The process wasn’t cheap but it cost less than a new R9.
I’ve owned more than half a dozen sunburst Historic Gibson Les Pauls, including two Murphys and a Florian Jaeger refin, plus a few Historic Goldtops and two Terry Morgan replicas. Many people think the Morgans are amazing but my two were no better than a couple of the R9s I’ve had, unless you care about the minutiae of control and tailpiece placement, control plate position etc - which I don’t personally. I do care about having the word Gibson on a correctly shaped headstock though, so none of the nearly-Gibsons have ever been a realistic alternative for me. Before anyone chimes in, yes I know that means I’m missing out on lots of other great guitars etc but that’s my choice and I’m happy with it.
The only sunburst LP I’ve kept is a 2005 R9, on which I’ve had the fretboard replaced with Brazilian and proper inlays, plus I’ve changed the pickups and all of the hardware and plastics for aged stuff. It’s not a ‘real’ burst and never will be, and it doesn’t have any lacquer checking or other induced body ageing. But fundamentally it’s a great playing and great sounding guitar, and it looks lovely, and that’s all good enough for me.
As has been said, play as many as you can and make your own mind up. Personally I need to play a guitar for a couple of months before I know it’s a keeper, hence buying and selling quite a few burst types over the years. Good luck with the hunt and enjoy it, it’s a great journey which might take a few years with several stops along the way!
https://imgur.com/a/x54joUt
For a few reasons, firstly - they are attainable for a mere mortal such as I. From player grade to unmarked. 'Bursts aren't. I'd rather have a real guitar in hand, than a pipe dream in me head.
Secondly, in and off themselves, they are exceptional guitars that I absolutely love playing. Better or worse than a 'Burst is a road I'd rather not issue forth on..but I've yet to hear a single one that can't hold it's own in any company. There is a certain neck on a certain 57 that in my modest opinion is one of the best Gibson necks I've ever had the pleasure of playing...seriously. I really didn't want to return it to it's rightful owner...I was gonna pretend I was out when he came for it.
Thirdly, I'm boycotting Gibson after they sacked the Custom shop leaders. Not bought a single Gibson product since Ed Wilson got the spanish. So the R's after a certain date are off the table for me. Loads of great guitars in the Wilson/Gember era knocking about. I highly rate a 2001 Murphy that I had.
Lastly, Fakes. The puritan in me refuses to countenance them, but undeniably the ones I have played have been so good that they've made a fool out of me. I just can't bring myself to buy into the delusion of them though. Others have no such issues, and that's fair play.
What therefore would I do in the OP's position? I'd buy the 59 Special in the classifieds ( oh wait...bugger..Hee hee ) and invest in the best Les Paul that my wallet could stand, that wouldn't necessarily have to say Gibson on the headstock if I'm being candid.
Helpful? Hardly, but I'm glad I've got that off me chest...
That's a stunning looking Les Paul!
Does it sound much different with the Brazilian rosewood fretboard?
@designerseye88 The very same...."Burst Killer"
(formerly miserneil)
The best replica I've played for years I own and that is an early 57 Gold Top Tom Murphy and still stock - have thought about pick up changes many times, but it ain't crap as it stands, so I keep thinking why go through the hassle for potential marginal gains ???
I'm lucky enough to have played 3 or 4 genuine 59's including the Moore/Green for about 15 mins - What ever magic Gary saw in it obviously suited him, but I did not get the vibe when I played it
The good news is that despite various negative vibes out there, regarding the fact that the replicas are not 'correct', taking that out the equation, there are many good replicas regarding feel, tone
Like @fretfinder - I've played 2/3 Terry M replicas - To play they are fine, but not a shed load better than many other good Gibson replicas - There is a big buzz about the Terry M models, but I feel the hype is bigger than the end result - Not played a Gil Yaron, so can't comment
I did play a superb early 50's gold top to burst conversion a couple of years ago - Owned by someone local to me and he paid around $10K for it, at the time - Maybe the neck was to slim to be 'correct' for what it was meant to now portray, but nevertheless it played, looked and sounded awesome - Shed loads of character
Glad the replica market exists as otherwise we'd all be playing 'stock' production models - That sounds a snobby statement and it is not meant to be - But most of us won't get to own or play the real thing, so let's be happy with the vast selection of replicas that are out there - Try a few and you'll hopefully find one that really speaks to you - That is the one with your name on it
Unfortunately I'm never going to own a burst, goldtop etc, i doubt I'd even get a junior now they're creeping up and it's the same for alot of people
The look of a burst is a beautiful thing as well as a beatup goldtop, i played a real 58 and 54 goldtop, i still get regular access to compare my stuff and there wasn't enough difference to me that would warrant spending that kind of money on one, I'd rather have a cobra, even then that'd be a replica lol, now the 54 is the one I'd have gladly taken home, there was a difference in unplugged tone and i still chase that bloody tone
I've heard the same about Morgans too and one recently that was dead and the guy still bought it then was looking at getting it to sound good, if it's not good why buy the thing, i bet it wasn't cheap
No one can tell you what you should buy but you need to play them whatever it is
(formerly customkits)