It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Subscribe to our Patreon, and get image uploads with no ads on the site!
This is OBVIOUSLY going to be highly contentious...but again - what is your view! I'm not slamming anyones preference here - each to their own!
Now that said, me personally I've never played any custom shop Fenders or Gibsons. I've always used the American standards/Gibson Standard/traditionals....and for me these are perfectly good enough. The look/feel/sound good and like they're 'supposed' to sound. Now again I've never tried one in the flesh. Closest I've experienced to any custom shop is to ogle them on shop walls up close. (I have tried LP Customs and they're custom shop now aren't they...but they just seemed to be more blinged up thats all) When I here such guitars demo'd, well - they sound like Strats/Teles/Les Pauls! They don't ever make me think "wow that's so much better than mine...I must have one!" So luckily for me I don't have any desire to spend that much more on them. Do they feel that much better ? I'm not gonna even entertain they sound any better cos they don't when I've seen/heard them demo'd. But I'm asking cos as I said never tried 'um ! The aged/relics aren't for me that's just pure personal preference. So aged cosmetics is just something that I personally have no desire for...fair do's to them that like it and are willing to pay for it. Not for me. But feel/sound/looks count to me.
So - Feel - no experience of.
Sound - to me they just don't sound better...and electronics pups etc can change that anyway to ones personal preference.
Looks - well for ME they don't look any better.
Am I a luddite in the dark and don't know what I'm missing ? ;-)
What I will concede is this - I've tried many cheaper Fenders like the Mex/Squiers, and copy Gibson alikes such as Tokai/Epiphone/Vintage etc and here I can discern definitely a more classy feel. And of course the wood does look nicer when its a real nice slab of flame maple over say a photo flame. So I can detect a quality improvement as you go up the price ladder...but that old chestnut of diminishing returns crops up here - Once you get to USA Standard level after that well...you tell me how much better do they feel/look ? I have for many years settled on that shelf and feel happy here....and yet you believers may just think "ignorance is bliss"
Base theme by DesignModo & ported to Powered by Vanilla by Chris Ireland, modified by the "theFB" team.
Comments
That said, a lot of Custom Shop guitars do feel really nice, some having that indefinable "something" over standard.
As a pub-gigging hack though, if you can't define it, then I'm buggered if I'm paying for it.
exactly!! That's what I am a pub/club gigger and teacher. I doubt i'll be changing my views but it is nice to hear what others think. As you said if there is some magical feel to a guitar over an American Standard then that is something that could tempt me down the line. But here and now, the American Standard is what feels good to me that is the 'standard' baseline for me. And something a lot more expensive would have to offer something really special in terms of extra tone/feel/looks to warrant/justify it.
Whats that old pic on the web somewhere I saw once on FB...ah found it. Teh troof...
https://ih1.redbubble.net/image.136078927.8222/flat,550x550,075,f.u3.jpg
It doesn't matter about all the marketing bollocks (and that is what most of it is)
However, the best guitar I own is a custom shop fender :-)
Had a quick play and thought it was cracking for the money. After buying the missus her bits I asked her to put it on my chrimbo list.
Clearly the rule of 'diminishing returns' is a factor - and for some, the quality improvement doesn't reflect the gulf in price - but that doesn't mean that there isn't a significant difference. To some extent this is moot if you can't afford - or don't see the need to own - a high end guitar.
Custom Shop Fenders are generally the best guitars Fender has made since the 60s - they are the 'no compromise' option. If bought used, they're great value - but still a lot of money.
The Nitro finish (albeit modern nitro, probably over a ply base) was less shiny and more tactile.
The pickups were hugely better.
The neck was far far nicer, fatter more interesting shape, heavily rolled edges and a masterful fret job, all add up to a sublime feel.
Does it sound any better, yes definately, twice as good as the Amercian Standard. Probably not, but that's not the point really.
*An Official Foo-Approved guitarist since Sept 2023.
Once you get into the non-fashion guitar market then the instrumental focus becomes sharper and concepts such as brand and model ranges of less significance.
It's true, of course, that expensive gear doesn't make a better player, but having a great-sounding, really playable guitar can encourage you to pick it up and practice.