It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Subscribe to our Patreon, and get image uploads with no ads on the site!
Base theme by DesignModo & ported to Powered by Vanilla by Chris Ireland, modified by the "theFB" team.
Comments
It wasn't particularly clear, but his having intercourse with his stalker was meant as a fantasy. This was marked by Martha repeating a line she said to him earlier on: “You’ve been hurt, haven’t you?”. That may be a misquote but it’s along those lines. It then cuts away from the fantasy.
I only watched it the other day with zero knowledge of it. At first, I thought it was interesting. Midway through, and despite the grim episodes (I don’t mind challenging TV, though it was a hard watch), something about it didn’t sit right. By the end, I thought it was all wrong.
Maybe some, all, or none of it is true. But whatever the case, I think the show paraded a horrible sense of depravity, was cleverly spun to get us to see how he wants us to see it and was generally a bad idea on various levels. It's a disturbing show, which is inflammatory and lacks sensitivity – to call it a comedy is wholly misleading (and a bit twisted). IMHO it would have been better without Gadd playing himself, told as a linear story to give an authentic portrayal of events and presented in a less besmirching way. Better still, a well-written book with more self-reflection would perhaps be more redeeming. For better or worse, I thought it was interesting, but I think there's probably a lot more to it.
Also, Gadd comes out of it all in a pretty poor light; arguably, with less sympathy from the audience than ‘Martha’ gets. I don’t know what he was thinking, sharing this with the world, and I do think there is something very needy and uncomfortable about the fact he did so…I am also not sure why people involved in the show didn’t all just shout it down as a very bad idea….but…. fascinating TV all the same.
That aside, I agree with everything you said and thought the same. I'm surprised it was signed off in its current form, and Gadd reenacting his traumas all for the world to see seems unethical and unhealthy – I just don't think he or Netflix thought about it or went about it in the right way. But yeah, fascinating despite being foolish.
E2A: Black Comedy is one of its categories.
Don't know if it was that "disturbing".
A guy that's maybe never had, and doesn't know how to have, a "normal" relationship.
There's nothing wrong with a relationship with a trans girl, it definitely felt more about his messed up view of relationships. Probably stemming from the abusive relationship with the older man.
Don't know if it would have had the same effect if it was a woman going back to an abusive heterosexual relationship?
It's certainly got people talking though.
Maybe I've watched too many "true crime" docs. but I've definitely heard more disturbing true stories.